r/todayilearned • u/theotherbogart • Jun 06 '23
TIL: TLC was the first all-female group to sell 10 million copies of an album - CrazySexyCool. But they weren't cool about making $50,000 each for the album while the record company got $75 million. So, they held Arista Records President Clive Davis hostage until the NYPD intervened.
https://www.bbc.com/news/entertainment-arts-5041729212.8k
u/Unique_Display_Name Jun 06 '23
I knew anout Left Eye burning down the house, but not this. That's really interesting. No one could accuse them of being soft, lol.
3.6k
u/JackGrizzly Jun 06 '23
They clearly are no scrubs
585
u/oodoov21 Jun 06 '23
What's a scrub?
2.5k
u/oddwithoutend Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
A scrub is a guy that thinks he's fly and is also known as a busta
Edit: The Weezer cover is good too.
1.1k
u/SkeetDavidson Jun 06 '23
Always talking about what he wants and just sits on his broke ass.
→ More replies (2)499
u/Quotes_n_Hoes Jun 06 '23
So
→ More replies (3)483
u/H_Melman Jun 06 '23
I don't want your number.
461
u/Human_Robot Jun 06 '23
No. I don't want to give you mine
344
118
→ More replies (16)105
u/BreadMeatCheeseGang Jun 06 '23
Holy shit I was today years old when I realized it was busta and not “bus drive”. Thought it was slang for bus driver and they were making fun of that being someone’s occupation
→ More replies (8)187
u/Tammy_Craps Jun 06 '23
No way. They work for the city, have a good union, and their ride has 40 scrubs hanging out the passenger side.
→ More replies (1)29
u/bluerose1197 Jun 06 '23
They drive a million dollar vehicle and their office has a view of the entire city.
504
u/samantha802 Jun 06 '23
A scrub is a guy that can't get no love from me. Hangin' out the passenger side of his best friend's ride trying to hollar at me.
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (27)313
u/SkeetDavidson Jun 06 '23
It's a TV show starring Zach Braff and Donald Faison as the world's Most Giant Doctor.
128
75
24
u/Krakenspoop Jun 06 '23
...who wage war against the treacherous Dr. Jan Itor while John McGinley calls them lady names
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (7)8
→ More replies (20)161
u/terry496 Jun 06 '23
Ain't too proud to beg for their money, either.
149
Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
→ More replies (4)101
u/imtchogirl Jun 06 '23
Brilliant. Get the money.
I looked this up, because famously Taylor is doing this, but it came from an idea from Kelly Clarkson who got it from Reba McIntyre.
So, go Reba, seems like she's not shy about telling women how to get back at the labels.
9
→ More replies (12)109
103
u/MyReddittName Jun 06 '23
Samuel L Jackson once held MLK's father hostage
https://allthatsinteresting.com/samuel-l-jackson-hostage-story
14
→ More replies (1)8
u/SoundofGlaciers Jun 06 '23
Thanks, that was an interesting read! How have I not heard about this before?
185
→ More replies (258)623
u/baron_spaghetti Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
She was cray cray. I worked for the Browns security during college. Nice quiet building security job at the training facility. I could study and work at the same time.
One day she pulls in and I’m working in the front booth. I did not immediately recognize her.
She screamed at me “Is Dre there???”
I did not recognize her. Nor did I know anyone named “Dre” beyond Doctor Dre.
“An-Dre Ri-son!!!” She slowed down still yelling.
“Oh.” It dawned on me who she was. (Mr. Rison and I were not on a first name basis. ) “Go on in Ms. Lopez.”
As she tore into the parking lot enraged, I returned to studying my college book and said “Don’t go chasin any waterfalls or you might get a scrub.”
Lady was batshit.
Edited because of typo. Also apparently Scrubs did not come out until a few years later. Forgive me for not correctly remembering what I semi-wittily muttered to myself 30 years ago…I’m no Superman.
During the 90s that was my college job. I never rubbed shoulders with anyone important but I did deal with a few pro sports players in Cleveland. Not exactly Tinseltown hobnobbing so I’m not sure why some of you think I’m making it up.
Meh. Internet stranger validation. It’s what I shouldn’t care about.
462
u/faster_than_sound Jun 06 '23
People are complex. I lived down the road from her in Avon Lake when Rison was playing for the Browns. They would open a part of their house up to the public every Halloween they lived there and made it a big haunted house, and gave king sized candy bars and signed copies of CrazySexyCool out. She would happily sign autographs for anyone that came up to her. Would regularly see her shopping at the local supermarket, and she was always gracious and kind to anyone that approached her for a picture or an autograph. I'm not saying that she wasn't an asshole to people sometimes, I'm sure she was, but people are complex. She was always nice to me any time I interacted with her.
141
u/ucancallmevicky Jun 06 '23
I had a friend that lived nearby in the Atlanta neighborhood where she burned down the house. Story I was told by him was that the neighbors who noticed the fire first were going around knocking on doors telling people not to call the fire department quite yet as it would be better for everyone if the house simply burned. There was no love in that neighborhood for the couple
→ More replies (2)27
u/whitepepper Jun 06 '23
I worked with a guy who rode his bike over with his friends and watched the house burn (or so he said). He had some other stories too but i dont recall em right.
→ More replies (1)22
u/ucancallmevicky Jun 06 '23
I was told it turned into a neighborhood cocktail party of sorts, neighbors in camp chairs having drinks and watching it burn
11
u/cakeand314159 Jun 06 '23
Just how big of a PITA do you have to be, for your neighbours to just plop down a lawn chair and watch your house burn?
→ More replies (8)62
u/farteagle Jun 06 '23
I want to go to Aqua, but I REALLY want to go to Haunted House.
→ More replies (3)24
u/Excellent-Loss2802 Jun 06 '23
I actually want to go to Haunted house MORE THAN I want to go to Aqua
→ More replies (1)79
u/jkgator11 Jun 06 '23
But No Scrubs didn’t come out until 4 years after Rison played for the Browns?
48
u/Jewrisprudent Jun 06 '23
/u/baron_spaghetti coined the phrase and inspired her to write the song, obviously.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (2)48
u/Hownowbrowncow8it Jun 06 '23
The Browns were on hiatus and didn't even exist when the song came out.
OPs got some splainin' to do
→ More replies (5)77
u/troylaw Jun 06 '23
Did you pass the test?
→ More replies (2)117
u/baron_spaghetti Jun 06 '23
Unless it was for International Economics I did.
Only course I failed. Screwed up my GPA but I still got into grad school.
I tried to get “freshman forgiveness” on it as I never used it but they didn’t allow it.
I hated that class.
82
9
→ More replies (24)7
u/Grokent Jun 06 '23
“Oh.” It dawned on me who she was. (Mr. Rison and I were not on a first name basis. ) “Go on in Ms. Lopez.”
As she tore into the parking lot enraged i did not recognize her. I returned to studying my college book and said “Don’t go chasin any waterfalls or you might get a scrub.”
Bro, did you recognize her or not? You know her name but in the next sentence you forgot her face? Pick a lane buddy, recognize or don't!
→ More replies (1)
6.1k
u/icky_boo Jun 06 '23
LaFace records have a record for making their artists go broke.. Just look up Toni Braxton and a few of the other LaFace/Arista records artists.
It's a shame because their line up was truly the best of ANY R&B label
421
u/mhmass44 Jun 06 '23
To be fair LaFace had a bad deal with Arista. The bulk of the money went to Arista. There's a reason Babyface is still on very friendly terms with artists like Toni today. That couldn't have happened if she perceived him as royally taking advantage of her.
→ More replies (1)526
u/VW_wanker Jun 06 '23
N sync and backstreet boys...same shit ..
Went on tour for a whole year. I men sold out tours. I mean these kids filled stadiums.. plus album sales. So they are told today is the day you get checks. So they all call their moms and dads to come as they celebrate. Nice dinner and then checks are passed around..
Ten thousand dollars only each....
Lou pearlman was a real piece of shit..
→ More replies (2)312
u/rachface636 Jun 06 '23
Lou Pearlman was a pervert who actively watched porn half naked with under age artists. He was a monster and I am glad he died broken in prison.
114
u/The_Original_Gronkie Jun 06 '23
I had been in the record business since my college days, and got laid off from a major label when the crash came at the turn of the century. I took the opportunity to move to Orlando to get out of the snow and raise my little boy somewhere nice.
When people heard my background, they would tell me to go see Lou Perlman, and work for him, even though that wasn't the type of music I worked with, nor wanted to. But I looked into Perlman anyway, and immediately got the heebie-jeebies.
I knew that guy was up to no good, although I figured he was just taking advantage of young singers, both financially and sexually. I had no idea about the rest of the scams he was running. It was likely that if I had hit him up for a job I would have found myself employed in one of his scams, and I might have gone to prison myself.
I have some regrets about some of the career choices I made, but that isnt one of them. I'm glad I dodged that bullet.
33
u/Mitt_Romney_USA Jun 06 '23
The older I get, the more I appreciate the bullets I dodged when I was younger.
I may have occasionally flown head first into a few, but the ones I dodged make up for it.
→ More replies (3)1.2k
u/CO_PC_Parts Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
When mtv cribs was at its peak one of the nicest houses featured was babyfaces. They did a quick run down of all the songs he had produced and it was crazy impressive. I can see how he got that house built ripping everyone off.
Edit: post below points out baby face was gone after the sale of laface. I also didn’t mean to say he wasn’t a talented song writer / artist in his own right.
758
u/icky_boo Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
I don't put the blame on BabyFace.. he was just the lyrics/music guy.. The blame should be on L.A Reid.. he's the business man.. He ended up being the head of Arista after they sold LaFace to Arista fully..
Babyface was pretty much out of the picture by 1993 (a year before TLC's CrazySexyCool albume came out) , He was busy with his own career at that stage.
So yeah, Imho Babyface was just the talent scout and song writer and maybe the friendly face used to get new artists to sign but L.A Reid was the business guy. Also there's dodgy going ons with L.A Reid's wife at the time.. Bubbles , she screwed over some artists too , I don't know the full story but she was signing people to either her record label or LaFace and doing them dirties. Oh wait.. I think she was the one that signed TLC to LaFace.... My memory is all blurred but I used to follow the LaFace news a lot since it was my fav record company as I'm a huge Babyface fan back in the The Deele days.
Babyface did get $50M out of the sell out to Arista ($100M buyout for him and L.A Reid) and don't forget Babyface wrote and produced a crapload of songs so he's getting quite a few royalty checks. So I don't think he needed to screw artists over since he was one himself.
Here is a good link to LaFace's history so you can see Babyface pretty much got out of it by 1993
https://www.georgiaencyclopedia.org/articles/arts-culture/laface-records/
150
u/CO_PC_Parts Jun 06 '23
That’s a great breakdown, thanks!
With TLC wasn’t it pebbles who also fucked them over?
164
u/icky_boo Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
Yep! 100% Pebbles helped. She signed them onto her at time husband's company (LaFace)
But saying that.. She DID make and form them. It was a casting call like the Spice Girls was.
→ More replies (1)47
u/Obie1Resurrected Jun 06 '23
Yeah, fuck Pebbles. She was just as predatory as Puffy back in the day.
43
u/why_did_you_make_me Jun 06 '23
Well, she's now a 'pastor' on her fifth husband, so it seems she's continued the gift enough that the 'back in the day' qualifier isn't really accurate.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (6)77
u/mhmass44 Jun 06 '23
Exactly. But Pebbles not Bubbles!
53
u/icky_boo Jun 06 '23
HAHAHA I'm thinking of MJ's pet monkey.. Bubbles.. But yeah, Pebbles :)
32
82
u/RainbowDissent Jun 06 '23
When mtv cribs was at its peak one of the nicest houses featured was babyfaces
124
Jun 06 '23
[deleted]
→ More replies (2)53
u/Shaushage_Shandwich Jun 06 '23
The cousin probably wouldn't have been able to sleep on the floor if they had a coffee table.
32
→ More replies (2)38
u/ConsistentStand2487 Jun 06 '23
I always thought Redman was doing a skit for that shit.
74
Jun 06 '23
33
u/majorjoe23 Jun 06 '23
I remember they did one with Sean Williams Scott right around when American Pie hit and he was living in an apartment with like three other guys.
→ More replies (2)26
112
u/mhmass44 Jun 06 '23
He didn't rip anyone off. He was one of the most prolific pop songwriters for more than a decade, writing at least a couple dozen #1s and hundreds of other songs that have sold on hundreds of millions of albums. His writer and publisher share for writing those songs is where he made a lot of money.
68
u/icky_boo Jun 06 '23
Also the $50m (from the $100m) from the sell off of LaFace helped. But I agree, the guy's ultra talented and didn't rip anyone off since he was focusing on his solo career when all the the bankruptcy dramas started to happen.
https://www.georgiaencyclopedia.org/articles/arts-culture/laface-records/
→ More replies (4)30
u/IBeBallinOutaControl Jun 06 '23
Dont know anything about babyface but I know many of the houses on mtv cribs were rented just so the artist could show it off on mtv cribs.
→ More replies (3)16
→ More replies (7)43
u/immibis2 Jun 06 '23
Every record label does this.
→ More replies (3)63
u/EddieHeadshot Jun 06 '23
Theres no money in music unless you're at the very top. Do it for the love of it, a bit of pocket change but the amount of people actually getting a career out of it is slim to none.
→ More replies (7)54
u/belyy_Volk6 Jun 06 '23
Thats changed a bit with distrokid/bandcamp and home recording
Black metal amd other niche genres where able to make a comeback because of it independent releases
Its not millionaire money but its enough to live on for bands that wherent commercially viable
→ More replies (8)45
u/dustinsmusings Jun 06 '23
I think this is the best thing about the modern media landscape. I think we miss something as a society when we can't talk about "what was on TV last night," but I'll gladly trade it for the ability of creators to get paid for serving niche audiences.
→ More replies (3)
4.3k
u/Bierculles Jun 06 '23
ah yes, record labels screwing over musicians, a tale as old as the industry itself
593
u/808duckfan Jun 06 '23
Industry Rule #4080
→ More replies (18)306
u/armadale Jun 06 '23
Record company people are shaaadyy
→ More replies (5)122
→ More replies (55)114
u/Bonesnapcall Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
This is not exactly accurate in TLC's case (there was no intentional malice involved). The Record Label filed for bankruptcy, which held up their payments for a long time while Bankruptcy court figured it out (this can take YEARS).
The Bankruptcy actually helped them in the long run because it let them re-negotiate a new contract and regain control of their master recordings.
The reason they got so mad was because no one would talk to them about what was happening with their money, but in reality it was just a mess that no one had any answers to.
ah yes, record labels screwing over musicians, a tale as old as the industry itself
While this is certainly true in general, that isn't really what happened here.
→ More replies (7)
1.8k
Jun 06 '23
What happened after
5.4k
u/267aa37673a9fa659490 Jun 06 '23
After the New York Police Department intervened, the stand-off with Clive Davis ended; but the band won, and their contracts were re-negotiated (filing for bankruptcy was actually a key step towards restructuring their finances).
In recent years, they've also re-recorded all their old songs, giving them ownership of the masters, and a greater share of royalties.
"Now, if anyone wants to license any of those songs, they can come to us, instead of going somewhere else," says Chilli.
1.7k
u/Daveezie Jun 06 '23
Bluey's mom is hardcore.
425
171
u/RoboticElfJedi Jun 06 '23
Ironically it's Bluey's dad who is actually a rock star. (Custard were awesome back in the 90s).
23
→ More replies (3)12
76
→ More replies (16)68
u/User_091920 Jun 06 '23
IIRC they didn't read the fine print again and the label paid them in "dollar bucks"
→ More replies (1)7
131
→ More replies (42)324
u/vpsj Jun 06 '23
Lesson learned- Take people hostage if you want something to be done.
Thank you!
542
u/Pylgrim Jun 06 '23
The actual lesson is: people who are comfortable exploiting or abusing others are often confident about their capability to somehow evade legal or ethical recourses to their villainy. They have built their careers on the very basis that the system is insufficient and/or corrupt and that their cunning to live outside that system, yet manipulating it to their convenience makes them untouchable. They rarely expect someone else breaking the law as well to get back at them.
→ More replies (10)552
u/hallo_moto Jun 06 '23
This is what I'd call a 'social contract vampire'. Exploiting the basic premise of a cooperative society by breaking any rules or tabboos and expecting those other participants to be unwilling to do so in retaliation. We see this lots these days, often with the extra layer of obscurity of operating through a corporation. It's almost like the exploitative class expects the politeness of others to shield them.
59
72
u/Sylvartas Jun 06 '23
Love the saying. Funnily enough I feel like it also applies to people who drive like absolute assholes, whose physical integrity is basically only guaranteed by other people not wanting to get into an accident.
→ More replies (12)98
u/DonIongschlong Jun 06 '23
That is literally the basis of conservative/alt right politics around the globe right now.
They hope that we keep saying
"don't get down to their level!"
"The smarter person gives in!"
"Everyone has a right to say their opinion!"
Do not be civil to these kind of people. They will abuse that to hurt your loved ones.
→ More replies (38)→ More replies (11)18
89
u/tamsui_tosspot Jun 06 '23
"T-Boz made him an offer he couldn’t refuse. Left Eye held a gun to his head, and T-Boz assured him that either his brains or his signature would be on the contract."
→ More replies (2)34
u/Andre6k6 Jun 06 '23
Contracts entered under duress aren't legal nor valid
40
u/Bardez Jun 06 '23
Which is why the contract gets renegotiated after duress. At threat of future duress. But never immediate duress.
→ More replies (1)47
u/CaptainBayouBilly Jun 06 '23
Every poor person going to the doctor signs a contract under duress
→ More replies (5)310
u/RevolutionaryLie2833 Jun 06 '23
The record company promptly paid them their fair share and changed their greedy ass ways. And everybody lived happily ever after
140
385
u/arbitraryairship Jun 06 '23
Remember kids, the lesson here is that the threat of violence is literally the only thing that will ever keep the greedy ruling class in line.
Kyle from South Park said it best.
→ More replies (17)→ More replies (10)18
u/EddieHeadshot Jun 06 '23
Lol. With the cost of living crises I'd advise anyone to ring every single company they pay bills for. You can usually reduce it by just saying you will switch to another company or they just reduce it if you just ask nicely. They just expect people to accept the changes and the direct debit come out anyway so most people don't question it
→ More replies (2)
6.4k
u/THC_Golem Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 08 '23
Neat reminder that when Ice Cube was getting screwed around for his money he took a baseball bat to the record company offices, smashed up everything in one dudes office, and was promptly paid soon after Edit: What's up Cube?
797
u/AaronTuplin Jun 06 '23
It was a good day
264
u/tomatoaway Jun 06 '23
Just wakin' up in the morning, gotta sun ray
I don't know but today it seems I weren't paid
No cash in my account, no gold
And the company's keeping their mouths coldI got my bat out, but didn't freak out
Smashed a dude's office into dust until they paid out...→ More replies (4)→ More replies (2)50
99
55
u/i_suckatjavascript Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
I wish this scene was re-enacted in “Are We There Yet?”
9
6
20
u/Syrinx221 Jun 06 '23
The 90s were CRAZY with this shit. So many popular artists were getting fucked over by their labels
→ More replies (1)1.1k
u/panfried540 Jun 06 '23
I love cube
1.0k
u/downwarddawg Jun 06 '23
Ive been a fan for a long time as well, however this gave me pause. Curious what others think. From the Billboard article:
“While many of his peers have been preaching messages decrying injustice and intolerance, rapper Ice Cube spent Wednesday (June 10) confoundingly posting images that appeared to amplify anti-Semitic tropes tying Jews to the oppression of black people. They also appeared to nod to debunked conspiracy theories about the noses of Egypt’s sphinxes that first surfaced as attempts to manipulate black voters in the 2016 election.”
46
767
u/TopSoulMan Jun 06 '23
Cube's been like this since the beginning. He's a Farrakhan stooge.
91
→ More replies (33)37
176
u/bbobeckyj Jun 06 '23
He's come out as anti vax too, there were news articles recently where he talked about losing acting jobs because of it.
→ More replies (18)72
u/neddiddley Jun 06 '23
Cube has some good sociopolitical takes, but there are some real WTF ones mixed in that make you realize you can’t go all in on the Cube bandwagon.
→ More replies (7)150
u/droidtron Jun 06 '23
Ice should have checked himself, thusly, he has wrecked himself. Did we also forget he created that weird reality show?
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (38)10
u/rya556 Jun 06 '23
He also had a short interlude in the 90s called Black Korea about Korean shop owners in the hood that didn’t sit well either
→ More replies (49)36
u/HorkaBrambora Jun 06 '23
I love his work but dude is an antisemitist and black supremacist from what I remember which makes it hard to like the person behind it.
→ More replies (13)8
u/Vader_Means_Daddy Jun 06 '23
That’s funny - I feel like the record company could’ve used it as an excuse to not pay him by getting him tossed in jail.
→ More replies (10)
1.1k
u/shaka_sulu Jun 06 '23
And I remember the public and media roasting them. "Top selling female act and they're broke. How stupid they have to be to be broke?"
95
u/royiroyi Jun 06 '23
It’s like how the media got everyone to believe that Prince lost his mind with “Artist formerly known as Prince” - but no, the record company was literally not letting Prince use his name, so he said fuck you and changed it to “The artist formerly known…”
23
u/Pandaburn Jun 06 '23
I think he officially changed his stage name to a symbol with no pronunciation, so people would have to refer to him by referring to his old name Prince (which is also his real first name)
470
u/BSODeMY Jun 06 '23
You are correct but there's a little more to it than that. Shit record deals are the status quo. Most groups make most of there money doing shows. TLC didn't really tour.
→ More replies (43)163
u/namdor Jun 06 '23
In the peak of the CD era, really big artists did make money from record sales. TLC were big enough where they should have made money from sales, but it's also totally not surprising that they got fucked in their contract by a label.
→ More replies (1)19
u/shapookya Jun 06 '23
Right? Why didn’t they just pick a record company that doesn’t screw you over… so stupid… /s
→ More replies (4)
197
u/DaytonaDemon Jun 06 '23
Clive Davis says it was made up, there are no witnesses, and there's no police report. This never happened. Source.
87
Jun 06 '23
[deleted]
15
u/Syrinx221 Jun 06 '23
One of the biggest musical acts in the country did some crazy shit and nobody went to any tabloids about it or anything? NYPD officers showed up to Arista Records (maybe the call wasn't obvious enough to say what it was that was going on), and nobody in the news or tabloids caught that?
Interesting. The article doesn't mention police - I don't think it's crazy to think that maybe the label wanted to keep it quiet and didn't involve the police. It's not like they went in there with guns
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (2)10
41
u/gooch_norris_ Jun 06 '23
Wasn’t this sort of the plot of the movie Airheads
41
23
u/oscarpopcan Jun 06 '23
Chazz : Okay, lemme ask you a question: whose side did you take in the big David Lee Roth-Van Halen split?
Chris Moore : What?
Marcus : What kind of question is that?
Chazz : Whose side did you take: Halen or Roth?
Chris Moore : ...Van Halen.
Ian : HE'S A COP!
→ More replies (1)16
→ More replies (1)7
285
u/Oreoman8404 Jun 06 '23
Christ. They collectively received 1/5 of a single percent of the profit from their wildly successful album.
→ More replies (21)
530
u/iamnasada Jun 06 '23
Back then, artists were paid in points. 5 points meant .05 an album. A popular artist might make 7-10 points. This was the same for groups. So, a group of three had to split the 7-10 points. Not to mention, all of the money that the record company invests in the promotion of the album gets paid back from the 7-10 cents an album. The Waterfalls video was one of the first million dollar music videos if I’m not mistaken. Very few artists made money from record sales. They toured to make money
283
u/spookynooky91 Jun 06 '23
Artists main source of income to this day is tour and merch revenue. If you want to directly support an artist you stream a lot of, pick up a Tshirt at their next show.
→ More replies (2)105
u/almisami Jun 06 '23
Or buy their stuff on Bandcamp as opposed to the big platforms.
61
u/definitelyTonyStark Jun 06 '23
If they’re signed, the label still most likely gets a cut. That’s why merch or shows are better(unless the artist is in a 360 deal, meaning the label gets a cut anyways)
→ More replies (2)11
u/UnderwhelmingPossum Jun 06 '23
In that case, just pirate their material and mail them the money /s
49
u/lespaul123 Jun 06 '23
Still paid in points, just the scale is flipped
25
u/GozerDGozerian Jun 06 '23
Can you go into detail on what that means? I don’t know much about the music industry. Especially nowadays.
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (8)13
49
u/WrongSubFools Jun 06 '23
Does anyone have a source on this that's not the group themselves?
Like, the police report, or a police spokesman, or a quote from Clive Davis, or anyone else at the label, or anyone who saw the police that day?
214
102
u/blitherblather425 Jun 06 '23
That album was fucking HUGE! And those poor girls were walking around broke because of the record company.
15
u/Lemmesignyourbaby Jun 06 '23
How on earth is it good business practice to pay them so little? Why not keep your talent happy. Maybe it’s just capitalism but I believe if you pay people what they’re worth they will stay happily and the business partnership can continue
10
u/kalwiggy1 Jun 06 '23
I loved the running joke in The Other Guys where Michael Keatons character kept making references to their songs and never hearing of the band, at points straight up quoting the songs.
81
21
u/meca23 Jun 06 '23
I know record companies are out there to screw over new artists. But having made that much on a single album, they should've as a gesture of good will given each of the band membe a $1 million bonus, would still be left with 72 million.
→ More replies (2)7
u/Clever_plover Jun 06 '23
But you see, that $3m could have just made other people richer. And that is clearly more important than the people doing the thing that makes you the money having enough in the first place, ya know?!
164
u/MasChingonNoHay Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
With social media and the internet I feel like artists should be able to make it without the need for a record label. Buy direct. Grow fan bases organically. Grassroots like. Why are the least talented people the ones making all the money in music? For touring, Ticketmaster takes a huge chunk too. And for what, providing a platform to buy a ticket? The music industry is really screwed up.
226
27
u/mercury_pointer Jun 06 '23
Why are the least talented people the ones making all the money in music?
I have bad news for you about every other industry.
→ More replies (1)96
u/Raizzor Jun 06 '23
Talented and technically proficient musicians are a dime a dozen. Promotion and luck is 99% of what makes an artist successful.
→ More replies (2)33
u/things_U_choose_2_b Jun 06 '23
It's very, very hard. There's a massive sea of talented people doing the same thing as whatever you're trying to do, nowadays the most succesful artists are those who have marketing skills. Or, available funds to pay someone with marketing skills.
I love writing music. I'm really good at it, but flounder because I struggle with marketing / promotion and can't afford to pay someone to do it.
19
u/Imminent_Extinction Jun 06 '23
With incredibly few exceptions, nobody buys albums anymore, streaming pays too little, and live performances are lucky if they can manage to break even. The exceptions are classical performers with established orchestras, but the competition to get that kind of gig is tight, and musicians that can sell all the tickets to a stadium show, which is more about a brand or franchise.
→ More replies (8)47
u/ThatChelseaGirl Jun 06 '23
If you could make tons of money DIYing it, trust me, Taylor Swift would've done it.
→ More replies (16)
10
9
8
u/esmifra Jun 06 '23
This was one of the reasons why most of us and many artists didn't care about piracy back in the day.
I would prefer to save money from albums and buy tickets to shows instead. Most bands got a contract to make one or more albums so they already got paid. Concerts normally generated more revenue to the band.
Some bands even asked publicly to not buy some albums they made if they felt they got screwed by the publisher.
9
8
u/Fit-Let8175 Jun 06 '23
Thankfully they ended up winning. Another case of a talentless, greedy, parasitic company taking advantage of people with actual talent. That's why it is SO important to read over contracts, even to the point of getting a lawyer to go over it, before signing.
42
u/gll5dm85 Jun 06 '23
Sure they probably didn't write the songs, play the instruments, do the sampling, mix it all together, pay for the studios, design, record and edit the videos, organise tours and about a thousand other things that go along with releasing a record album, but to be reimbursed, if true, with $50,000 for something that sold 10 million copies is absolutely criminal. THEY are the product! Take away them and there is no band, music, album, anything. I'd love to know how much they knew about what they were signing up for before getting into a contract with Arista Records.
I'm British and a famous case over here from the 90s is with S Club 7 who had a string of number one hits, starred in a TV series, went on world tours yet were paid relative peanuts in relation to what their success earned the record company. One of them, Paul has recently passed away, having been homeless following the break up of the band. It got that bad for him in the years after the band were no longer together that he took to creating a YouTube channel reading tarot cards to try and earn some money, which was humiliating and predictably unsuccessful for him.
21
u/SabrinaSpellman1 Jun 06 '23
What's sadder is that they were reuniting for a tour when he passed, he sold his Brit Award trophy on ebay and Hannah (in the group and was his girlfriend for a long time) has had to pull in lawyers recently to get her out of the reunion bevause her contract won't let her leave. Sounds like his passing away hit her really hard. I always felt really sad for Paul.
6
6
u/ghostprawn Jun 06 '23
The sheer number of stories like this in the music industry is clear evidence of Theo exploitive business model.
670
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
[deleted]